[Boost King]

For me it goes:

1. Gears Of War
2. Forza 2
3. Bioshock
4. Call of Duty 2
5. Halo 3 (sorry Halo fans)

I rank my games on a combined set of features, graphics, story and lastability or replayability.

Bioshock the number 1 Single player experience
Gears for the best online experience and also the most hours I've clocked into all of my games combined, has gone into gears.
Halo 3 because its Halo
Call of Duty series because it was a magnificent WW2 shooter.

Games upcoming that will place in the top 5.
- Gears 2
- Halo 4
- Bioshock 2
- GTA4
- COD4

I haven't mentioned Mass Effect cause I am not a huge RPG fan (other than Zelda) but thats more a adventure game etc, not a true RPG in essence. I think Mass Effect will be great, I really want to experience a demo first though to help decide.

Boost