[Pepper Jack]

personally i'd go for the premium, it's a great price and sooner or later you're gonna want those extras and trading in for yet another console will be an expensive option. granted the loudness of the console is an issue but i'd much rather take the extras over a quieter console. but on the other hand if the arcade version only leaves you without a hard drive it may be worth while to get the £100 arcade version and buy a 2nd hand hard drive for under £50 at a later date, they both seem like similar offers tbh.

and i think all consoles come with the live membership but don't quote me on that, also with the console being 2nd hand you may not get the live membership